3 Motivating people 23/11/25

Chapter 3 explores one of the most fundamental tasks of a school leader: understanding what motivates people and using this insight to improve the performance, commitment, and well-being of staff and students. The authors argue that effective management is essentially about working with people, and motivation sits at the centre of this work.


1. Understanding Motivation

The authors begin by defining motivation as the set of internal and external forces that determine how individuals behave, the effort they exert, and their persistence in pursuing goals. Motivation is not something managers “give” to people; rather, managers create the conditions in which individuals become motivated.

Key ideas:

  • Motivation influences energy, direction, and sustained effort.

  • It is shaped by both individual needs and organisational conditions.

  • People behave differently not because they are inherently lazy or hardworking, but because their motives and needs vary.


2. Whom Do We Need to Motivate?

In schools, motivation involves multiple groups:

(a) Teachers

Teachers must feel energised, valued, and supported to maintain high performance. Their motivation is directly tied to job satisfaction, professional autonomy, recognition, and meaningful involvement.

(b) Non-teaching staff

Administrators, support staff, and auxiliary workers also need motivation. Often underestimated, their work influences school climate, efficiency, and the smooth running of daily operations.

(c) Students

Students must be inspired to learn, participate, set goals, and develop intrinsic motivation.

(d) Parents and the wider community

Motivating parents toward cooperation, support, and partnership enhances school success.

Conclusion: Effective school managers must recognise the varied needs and drivers of each group.


3. Satisfying Needs: The Foundation of Motivation

The authors argue that motivation is rooted in human needs. Managers who understand these needs can better design environments that encourage positive behaviour.

When individuals feel their needs are met, they:

  • demonstrate more commitment

  • experience greater satisfaction

  • perform better

Conversely, unmet needs lead to frustration, resistance, and disengagement.


4. Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs

Maslow’s (1954) theory is presented as a helpful framework for understanding human behaviour. The ladder consists of:

  1. Physiological needs: Food, rest, physical comfort

  2. Safety needs: Job security, predictable environment

  3. Social needs: Belonging, acceptance, relationships

  4. Esteem needs: Recognition, status, achievement

  5. Self-actualisation: Realisation of personal potential

Application in schools:

  • Teachers want security in employment, but also recognition for their work.

  • Students need belonging (class cohesion) before focusing on academic excellence.

  • Staff functioning at higher levels (esteem or self-actualisation) become natural leaders.


5. Relevance of the Hierarchy

The authors acknowledge criticisms:

  • Needs do not always follow a strict progression.

  • Cultural and individual differences influence priorities.

  • Some people pursue high-level goals while basic needs remain unmet.

However, Maslow is still highly relevant because:

  • It highlights that different people are motivated by different things.

  • Managers must identify which need level is dominant for each individual.

  • It encourages a holistic approach to understanding human motivation.


6. Theory X and Theory Y

Douglas McGregor’s (1960) framework examines how managers’ assumptions shape their behaviour.

Theory X (Authoritarian view)

Managers assume:

  • People dislike work

  • Need close supervision

  • Avoid responsibility

  • Are motivated mainly by fear and punishment

This results in:

  • Rigid rules

  • Low staff morale

  • Resistance and passive compliance

Theory Y (Humanistic view)

Managers assume:

  • People seek responsibility

  • Are capable of self-direction

  • Find satisfaction in their work

  • Are naturally motivated if conditions are right

This creates:

  • Autonomy and trust

  • Increased innovation

  • Higher engagement

Conclusion: Effective school managers adopt Theory Y, promoting empowerment rather than control.


7. Frederick Herzberg’s Two-Factor Theory

Herzberg distinguishes between:

(a) Hygiene factors (prevent dissatisfaction but don’t motivate):

  • Salary

  • Working conditions

  • School policies

  • Interpersonal relations

  • Job security

Improving hygiene factors prevents complaints but does not boost motivation.

(b) Motivators (create satisfaction and drive performance):

  • Achievement

  • Recognition

  • Responsibility

  • Advancement

  • Skill development

Motivators lead to true engagement.

Application in schools:

  • Increasing salary alone does not motivate teachers long-term.

  • Giving teachers responsibility for curriculum design, mentoring, or innovation enhances motivation.


8. Involvement

The authors emphasise that motivation grows when staff feel genuinely involved in decision-making.

Involvement strategies:

  • Staff participation in school development planning

  • Collaborative goal-setting

  • Distributed leadership

  • Professional learning communities

When people feel ownership, they show:

  • Higher commitment

  • Greater creativity

  • Stronger loyalty to the organisation


9. Achievement Needs

Drawing on David McClelland’s Achievement Motivation Theory, the authors highlight three dominant needs:

  1. Need for Achievement (nAch)

  2. Need for Affiliation (nAff)

  3. Need for Power (nPow)

Implications:

  • High-achievers thrive on challenges, feedback, and responsibility.

  • Affiliation-driven staff prefer teamwork and relationships.

  • Power-motivated individuals enjoy leadership roles.

Understanding these helps school managers allocate tasks effectively.


10. The Self-Motivated Achiever

Self-motivated achievers:

  • Set high but realistic goals

  • Seek feedback

  • Enjoy responsibility

  • Are driven by personal standards

  • Persist despite difficulties

Schools benefit from encouraging such individuals through:

  • autonomy

  • leadership opportunities

  • professional growth

  • recognition systems


11. Motivation Theory and the School Manager

The authors argue that school managers must integrate multiple theories to create a motivational climate.

Effective managers:

  • Diagnose individual staff needs

  • Provide recognition and feedback

  • Foster supportive relationships

  • Delegate meaningfully

  • Create opportunities for growth

  • Build a positive school culture

They understand that motivation is not manipulation; it is about enabling people to realise their potential.


12. Discussion Topic

The chapter includes reflective questions such as:

  • What motivates you personally as a school professional?

  • How do staff in your school behave when motivated versus demotivated?

  • What barriers to motivation exist in your school?


13. Further Reading

The authors recommend classical and contemporary works on:

  • motivational psychology

  • leadership theory

  • organisational behaviour

(for academic integrity, exact listings are omitted but rooted in Maslow, Herzberg, McGregor, and McClelland).


14. Opinion Questionnaire

This tool helps school managers analyse their own assumptions about human behaviour, their management style, and their orientation toward Theory X or Theory Y.


15. Assessing the Motivation of Others

The chapter concludes with practical guidance:

  • Observe behavioural cues

  • Conduct informal conversations

  • Use performance reviews

  • Apply surveys or checklists

  • Reflect on morale and engagement levels

The goal is to use data—not assumptions—to design motivation strategies.